Conservative UK: Think tank calls for probe into Carrie Symonds’ role in ‘governing’

A Tory think tank has called for a probe into Carrie Symonds’ role in ‘governing’ the UK after Dominic Cummings’ ally Oliver Lewis quit his No.10 job.

Mr Lewis, who was one of Boris Johnson’s key Brexit advisors, resigned from his anti-Scottish independence role last night amid a new outbreak of infighting among the Prime Minister’s backroom team – where more allies of Carrie Symonds are taking key positions. 

The Bow Group today called for a review to clarify the ‘position and authority’ of the Prime Minister’s fiancee, amid concern over her influence within Number 10. 

Mr Lewis, right-hand man to chief Brexit negotiator Lord Frost (who was last week appointed to the cabinet), walked out of No 10 after he angrily denied claims of disloyalty.

The advisor, nicknamed Sonic due to his supposed resemblance to Sonic the Hedgehog, was reportedly told by the Prime Minister that he faced allegations of ‘briefing against the Government’.

But friends of Mr Lewis, an ally of Mr Johnson’s former chief adviser Dominic Cummings, said he strongly refuted the allegation. 

‘Oliver was deeply shocked and said he would never do such a thing, that he had worked tirelessly and loyally for the Prime Minister and felt he had no choice but to resign,’ said one friend.

His resignation is the latest evidence of what one government source referred to as the ‘non-stop Downing Street psychodrama’.

The Bow Group said an inquiry should look at Ms Symonds’ role in Downing Street, details of any official meetings she has attended, and orders given by her to special advisers and civil servants.

The group, which describes itself as the oldest conservative think tank in the world, said the inquiry should also look at her ‘possible influence’ in Government hiring and appointments.

Ben Harris-Quinney, chairman of the Bow Group, said Ms Symonds ‘currently holds no official role in the Conservative Party or the Government, yet consistent reports in the press suggest that Ms Symonds is taking a central role in running the country, without any authority or accountability to do so’.

He added: ‘She has not been elected, she has not been appointed, she holds no legal or constitutional powers to make decisions relating to who should hold government posts, to be party to privileged information, or to set the policy direction of the country.

‘It is therefore urgent that a review and inquiry takes place to determine what Ms Symonds’ role in the governing of the United Kingdom is, and has been to date.

‘Failure to clarify Ms Symonds’ position and authority, and to ensure that Ms Symonds is not and cannot take any action in governing the United Kingdom, potentially has huge hazards for the Government, the Conservative Party, and the nation.

‘The public take a very dim view of cronyism, democracy in Britain is and must always be sacred, and no one should be involved in running our country without accountability to the people.’

Patrons of the Bow Group include Conservative peers Lord Tebbit and Lord Lamont, as well as MPs John Redwood and Sir Bill Cash and former MP Ann Widdecombe.

Reports say Mr Lewis left after he was blamed by Miss Symonds and her allies for leaking.

An ally of Mr Lewis told The Times: ‘On Thursday the prime minister b******ed Oliver [for leaking], so he reached the conclusion that Carrie was in charge now and the prime minister wasn’t going to have his back any more. 

‘It’s a complete Carrie takeover.’ 

Reports say Miss Symonds, nicknamed ‘Princess Nut Nut’ by Cummings allies, had been a key player in the removal of Dominic Cummings and former director of communications Lee Cain – as well as being involved in the decision to bring in Baroness Finn as deputy chief of staff and senior advisor Henry Newman. 

Ms Symonds was reportedly labelled a ‘princess’ for what her foes claimed was regal behaviour while the ‘nut’ is believed to be a poor-taste joke about her being ‘crazy’.  

The slur went viral as the extraordinary power struggle between the PM’s fiancee and the Vote Leave cabal emerged in public last November

But in fact it is said to have been circulating since the early days of Boris Johnson’s premiership, with tensions evident from the outset.  

A source told the Mail on Sunday that the nickname had been wrongly reported as ‘Princess Nut Nuts’.  

‘It’s Princess Nut Nut,’ they said, before revealing that Ms Symonds’ adversaries used the phrase so often during the general election that they started using an emoji of a princess followed by two peanuts instead of words in text messages. 

A political ally of Mr Johnson said that it is now turning into ‘the court of Henry VIII’.   

‘Wolsey [Cummings] has had the chop and it all depends on who Anne Boleyn favours now,’ they said. 

Lewis had also allegedly been under fire from Mr Johnson’s new chief of staff Dan Rosenfield. A source told The Times: ‘Dan has wanted to get rid of Oliver too but it’s all coming from the same place. It’s a complete clearout of anyone associated with Dom [Cummings].’  

It comes after surprise changes this week. The Prime Minister’s appointment of Baroness Finn as the new deputy chief of staff at No 10, with Michael Gove’s former aide Henry Newman as her assistant, was seen as a mark of the growing political influence of Mr Johnson’s fiancee Carrie Symonds. 

The pair are friends with Miss Symonds, who previously worked at Tory HQ, and their promotions have enflamed tensions between the warring factions in Mr Johnson’s inner circle.

Lord Frost was given a Cabinet seat after threatening to resign over the Finn and Newman appointments. Both are allies of Michael Gove, the Cabinet Office minister, and Carrie Symonds.

Ben Gascoigne, the prime minister’s political secretary, also threatened his resignation and it is believed that at least two other senior officials are considering giving up their positions too.  

Last weekend Lord Frost, the architect of the prime minister’s Brexit deal, made clear to the prime minister that he was prepared to walk away.

He insisted that he would be leaving Downing Street but Mr Johnson responded by appointing him as a minister of state in the Cabinet Office, with the responsibility for overseeing the relationship with Europe – after Gove was stripped of his Brexit responsibilities.  

And it is understood that Mr Lewis made a similar threat.

He was reportedly on the brink of resigning in December after Mr Cummings left due to infighting but was persuaded to stay by Mr Johnson.

The Prime Minister rewarded Mr Lewis just weeks ago by putting him in charge of No 10’s ‘Union Unit’ which aimed to stop Scotland from breaking away from the UK.

He replaced Luke Graham, a former Conservative MP.

Mr Johnson told Mr Lewis to help Scottish-born Cabinet Office minister Mr Gove ‘build the case for preserving the Union’ in the run-up to Scottish elections in May.

Mr Lewis, who worked alongside Mr Cummings in the Vote Leave campaign in the 2016 EU referendum, won widespread praise for the way he helped Lord Frost in the Brexit talks.

He was appointed to lead Mr Johnson’s union unit two weeks ago and replaced former MP for Ochil and South Perthshire, Luke Graham, who had been in the job for less than a year.  

Mr Lewis was responsible for the decision to create a ‘narrative of the inevitability of Brexit’. And Mr Johnson wanted him to use his skills to counter Scottish Nationalist claims that independence is ‘inevitable.’

He advised the prime minister to set up a cabinet committee for the Union modelled on the Brexit committees that took charge of the final negotiations with EU officials.  

‘Oliver had already drafted a campaign to persuade people they could be passionate Scots and patriotic Britons at the same time,’ said one ally of Mr Lewis, adding: ‘It has all gone to waste because of petty squabbling and ruthless power politics.’

Oxford-educated Mr Lewis had worked closely with Michael Gove on No Deal preparations, and was inspired by Cummings’ love of science to construct an enormous spreadsheet to model difference scenarios styled on techniques used by NASA. 

Mr Lewis had previously played a pivotal role in Downing Street, serving as Lord Frost’s deputy on Brexit. He served as a Brexit adviser and has been involved in the crunch negotiations between the UK and the EU as the two sides hammered out the terms of a trade deal.  

The move comes after a Government source told The Times that there are ‘too many factions…in one small building all competing for one man’s attention and power’. 

One of the faction is made of long-standing Johnson Aides, another is made up of those left behind from Dominic Cummings’s days in power. 

There is a third group of officials appointed under new cabinet secretary Simon Case and a group of aides who are believed to be trusted friends of Carrie Symonds.   

It was claimed earlier this week that Boris Johnson gave a Cabinet seat to his former Brexit negotiator after he threatened to quit over a Downing Street power struggle.

Lord Frost was given Michael Gove’s job of overseeing the UK’s new relationship with Brussels and ‘driving through changes to maximise the opportunities of Brexit’.

In a massive promotion, he will become a full member of the Cabinet from March 1.

Insiders revealed the move was linked to an internal dispute over other recent key changes in the Prime Minister’s Downing Street inner circle, involving personal and political allies of his partner Carrie Symonds.

They claimed that Lord Frost, 55, had been opposed to Mr Johnson’s decision last week both to appoint Baroness Finn as deputy to new No.10 chief of staff Dan Rosenfield – and to appoint the ex-Gove aide, Henry Newman as her assistant. Both Baroness Finn and Mr Newman are close friends of Miss Symonds. 

The pair were in Mr Gove’s team when he famously betrayed Mr Johnson in the 2016 Tory leadership contest.

Baroness Finn and Mr Gove were an item when they left university. She also hosted Miss Symonds’s 30th birthday party in 2018, which was attended by both the Prime Minister and Mr Gove, while Miss Symonds, Baroness Finn and Mr Newman campaigned together in the 2019 election in Wales.

According to one source, Mr Johnson’s decision to give Lord Frost a Cabinet post was designed in part to stop him leaving Downing Street altogether. An ally of Lord Frost told the Daily Mail: ‘There was a real danger that Lord Frost would walk.

‘The new appointments in Rosenfield’s team dilute the power of those who have been loyal to Boris over many years. Giving Lord Frost a seat in the Cabinet redresses the balance.’ Supporters of Mr Gove last night denied giving Lord Frost a place in his ministerial team was a ‘snub’ to him – and insisted Mr Gove had suggested the idea himself.

Others maintained it is the latest evidence of deep seated tensions in Mr Johnson’s inner team.

They flared last year when Mr Johnson’s controversial senior Downing Street adviser Dominic Cummings and his ally Lee Cain were forced to resign. Mr Cummings and Mr Cain were both close to Lord Frost. But they were heavily criticised by Tory MPs – and critically, had fallen out of favour with Miss Symonds, 32.

Mr Johnson hoped the appointment last month of Treasury civil servant turned banker Mr Rosenfield as his new chief of staff would bring stability to his Downing Street machine. But some officials have claimed Mr Rosenfield has failed to make his mark and that there is a ‘lack of chemistry’ between him and Mr Johnson.

There have also been reports Mr Rosenfield has clashed with two more Johnson aides in Number 10, Lord Lister and Policy Unit chief Munira Mirza, both of whom – like Lord Frost – worked for Mr Johnson in his London mayoral days. 

It has been alleged that political advisers have been shut out of meetings and Mr Rosenfield, who is said to have sided with the Treasury’s suggestion that universal credit only be extended for six months rather than a year, is bringing in officials to brief Mr Johnson.  

Some advisers have complained that Rosenfield seems to want to stock Downing Street with civil servants in roles once occupied by political appointments. 

Miss Symonds counts Mr Newman as one of her closest confidants in politics. She sought his advice when weighing up whether to challenge the release from jail of John Worboys, the so-called Black Cab rapist, who targeted her when she was a teenager.

When her relationship with Mr Johnson became public in 2018, Mr Newman hit back at her critics, writing on Twitter: ‘Carrie Symonds coverage too often reflects a misogyny that attractive women can’t also be talented.’ 

Baroness Finn was one of around 90 women in Westminster to sign an open letter saying the treatment of the ex-Tory press officer had been ‘appalling’.

The trio have also taken to the streets together to help fellow Conservatives get elected – with her adopted puppy Dilyn.

The promotion of Lord Frost to the Cabinet Office prompted speculation that Scots born Mr Gove may be put in charge of a new Cabinet drive to stop Scotland breaking away from the UK.

The surprise announcement means Lord Frost replaces Mr Gove as chairman of the Cabinet committee tasked with implementing the Brexit divorce agreement. Lord Frost yesterday praised the way Mr Gove had handled talks with the EU, saying ‘I stand on the shoulders of giants.’

Mr Gove said there was ‘no one better to take forward our post-Brexit relationship with the EU.’

Mr Gove will keep his Cabinet table seat and as Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster remains above Lord Frost in the Cabinet Office pecking order. 

It has been claimed that Mr Gove is being considered for a move in a June reshuffle. 

A source told the Times that after he challenged Mr Johnson during the 2016 leadership campaign there has been a ‘trust deficit’ between the pair.    

The SNP’s Westminster deputy leader Kirsten Oswald claimed Mr Johnson’s ‘taxpayer-funded anti-independence campaign is completely falling apart’.

‘As support for independence grows, the Tories are losing advisers like rats on a sinking ship. People in Scotland have a right to determine their own future in a post-pandemic referendum. Boris Johnson knows he cannot deny democracy any more than Donald Trump.

‘The issue at the election in May will be this: who has the right to decide what sort of country we should be after the pandemic – the people of Scotland or Boris Johnson? The only way to ensure Scotland’s future is in Scotland’s hands not Boris Johnson’s is with both votes SNP.’

Downing Street declined to comment on staffing matters.

The Symonds allies with key roles at No 10: The ex-girlfriend of Michael Gove who ‘convinced him to pull the rug out from Boris Johnson’s 2016 leadership bid’ and ex-Cameron era Cabinet Office aide appointed to PM’s ‘court of King Henry’ 

Shockwaves were sent through No 10 after Boris Johnson appointed two new aides, one of whom is the ex-girlfriend of Michael Gove.

Baroness Simone Finn was appointed as deputy chief of staff and Henry Newman was made a senior adviser of Downing Street. 

The pair are not only allies of Cabinet Office minister Michael Gove but also the prime minister’s fiancee, Carrie Symonds.   

Mr Johnson last week decided to appoint Baroness Finn as deputy to new No.10 chief of staff Dan Rosenfield – and to appoint the ex-Gove aide, Mr Newman as her assistant.  

The pair have worked together before and were in Mr Gove’s team when he famously betrayed Mr Johnson in the 2016 Tory leadership contest.

However, they are reportedly often invited to the Downing Street flat by Mr Johnson and Ms Symonds, unlike Mr Gove.  

Baroness Finn and Mr Gove were an item when they left university. She also hosted Miss Symonds’s 30th birthday party in 2018, which was attended by both the Prime Minister and Mr Gove, while Miss Symonds, Baroness Finn and Mr Newman campaigned together in the 2019 election in Wales.  

A political ally of Mr Johnson said that it is now turning into ‘the court of Henry VIII’.   

‘Wolsey [Cummings] has had the chop and it all depends on who Anne Boleyn favours now,’ they said. 

Lewis had also allegedly been under fire from Mr Johnson’s new chief of staff Dan Rosenfield. A source told The Times: ‘Dan has wanted to get rid of Oliver too but it’s all coming from the same place. It’s a complete clearout of anyone associated with Dom [Cummings].’ 

Ms Symonds was reportedly instrumental in removing Cummings from No 10, along with Lee Cain, Mr Johnson’s former director of communications. She also played a role in bringing Baroness Finn and Mr Newman into their new roles.  

A source told The Times: ‘This is her tribe, these are her people. If she wasn’t [engaged] to Boris then she’d be working for him in a senior position in Downing Street. They are a loving couple and he values her opinion but she is a force in her own right.’

Baroness Finn worked with mr Newman for just under five years while David Cameron was in power.  

She is an ex-girlfriend of Gove but knows Mr Johnson well after running his fundraising campaign when he stood as mayor of London. 

One source said that Finn had been one of Gove’s aides who convinced him to ‘pull the rug out’ from under Johnson in the 2016 leadership race. 

Mr Newman is a friend of Ms Symonds, who has in the past tagged him in a group photograph of Tory canvassers on Twitter as one of ‘four of my favourite people’. 

Lord Frost, the negotiator behind Mr Johnson’s Brexit deal, threatened to resign over the new appointments made last week over concerns his role as Brexit adviser was being marginalised. 

Not wanting to lose a valued adviser, Mr Johnson appointed Mr Frost as a minister of state in the Cabinet Office – letting him oversee the country’s relationship with Europe. 

Oxford-educated Baroness Finn has been a member of the House of Lords since 2015 and was appointed as a non-executive board member for the Cabinet Office in May last year before her promotion. 

After leaving university she worked as an accountant for PwC before being recruited by the Conservative party in 2010 as the Coalition Government’s industrial relations adviser.  

In 2019, Mr Newman wrote of his admiration for Cummings: ‘Cummings is one of only a few political advisers who understands the importance of, and is truly committed to, reforming the Whitehall machine. 

‘I worked with another, Simone (now Baroness) Finn, in the Cabinet Office between 2012 and 2015.

‘As special advisers to Francis Maude (then the Minister for the Cabinet Office), Finn and I helped design and push forward a programme of Whitehall reform. It wasn’t about moving away from the Northcote–Trevelyan system of a non-political civil service, it was about making the machine work more effectively. 

‘At the time the big challenge was austerity – could you save money and yet provide better public services? Now the challenge is Brexit.’ 

An ally of Lord Frost told the Daily Mail: ‘There was a real danger that Lord Frost would walk.

‘The new appointments in Rosenfield’s team dilute the power of those who have been loyal to Boris over many years. Giving Lord Frost a seat in the Cabinet redresses the balance.’ Supporters of Mr Gove last night denied giving Lord Frost a place in his ministerial team was a ‘snub’ to him – and insisted Mr Gove had suggested the idea himself.

Others maintained it is the latest evidence of deep seated tensions in Mr Johnson’s inner team.

They flared last year when Mr Johnson’s controversial senior Downing Street adviser Dominic Cummings and his ally Lee Cain were forced to resign. Mr Cummings and Mr Cain were both close to Lord Frost. But they were heavily criticised by Tory MPs – and critically, had fallen out of favour with Miss Symonds, 32.

Mr Johnson hoped the appointment last month of Treasury civil servant turned banker Mr Rosenfield as his new chief of staff would bring stability to his Downing Street machine. But some officials have claimed Mr Rosenfield has failed to make his mark and that there is a ‘lack of chemistry’ between him and Mr Johnson. 

Reports say Miss Symonds, nicknamed ‘Princess Nut Nut’ by Cummings allies, had been a key player in the removal of Dominic Cummings and former director of communications Lee Cain – as well as being involved in the decision to bring in Baroness Finn as deputy chief of staff and senior advisor Henry Newman. 

Ms Symonds was reportedly labelled a ‘princess’ for what her foes claimed was regal behaviour while the ‘nut’ is believed to be a poor-taste joke about her being ‘crazy’.  

The slur went viral as the extraordinary power struggle between the PM’s fiancee and the Vote Leave cabal emerged in public last November

But in fact it is said to have been circulating since the early days of Boris Johnson’s premiership, with tensions evident from the outset.  

A source told the Mail on Sunday that the nickname had been wrongly reported as ‘Princess Nut Nuts’. 

‘It’s Princess Nut Nut,’ they said, before revealing that Ms Symonds’ adversaries used the phrase so often during the general election that they started using an emoji of a princess followed by two peanuts instead of words in text messages. 

A Government source said that Baroness Finn was appointed without consultation from Mr Rosenfield. 

A source told The Times: ‘Simone’s appointment was presented to Dan as a fait accompli. He had absolutely no say in the matter. That’s not the best start to the relationship.’

No 10 deny this and say Rosenfield was happy with Baroness Finn’s appointment.  

Another source said: ‘Carrie is not a pushover by any means and there are times when Boris just wants a quiet life. That is part of what’s going here.’