Moderna will submit their coronavirus vaccine for emergency approval

Moderna will today submit their Covid-19 vaccine for emergency approval after final results from trials show it is 94.1 per cent effective at preventing infections and the UK is set to approve Pfizer’s jab ‘within days’.

Final results from the companies stage 3 trials mark a landmark success for the vaccine, with only 11 out of the 196 volunteers who tested positive for the virus having received the jab. There are around 30,000 people in the study in total, each receiving two doses of the jab or a placebo.

The more than two-month study also found that no one who caught the virus after receiving the vaccine suffered a serious illness, and no safety concerns were raised with the jab.

Experts today heralded the results as ‘very good news’ and remarked they were ‘virtually identical’ to the early stage figure of 94.5 per cent – which was announced after 95 infections were confirmed, including five in people who had received the vaccine.

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the US was today sent the results along with a request for emergency approval. Regulators in the UK, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), were also handed the results to speed the vaccine through to patients earlier. 

As many as five million doses of the vaccine – which uses protein-building mRNA from the virus to trigger an immune response – were hastily ordered by the UK when the early trial results were announced this month. They are expected to begin arriving by next year.

The announcement follows hot on the heels of Pfizer and BioNtech, who said ten days ago they had also submitted their vaccine – which was up to 95 per cent effective in clinical trials and is also based on mRNA – for emergency approval by US regulators.

The UK is poised to become the first western country to approve this vaccine within days, reports the Financial Times, with deliveries of the 40million doses ordered expected to begin within hours of it receiving the green light from regulators. The first vaccinations could begin on December 7.

Oxford University has said its jab is up to 90 per cent effective against coronavirus when given as a half-dose and a full-dose, but this is based on results from only 3,000 participants following a mistake in the trials. Its vaccine is up to 60 per cent effective when two full doses are given, their data said. 

The UK has ordered 100million doses of the vaccine, which is based on Covid-19 spike proteins – used by the virus to infect cells – attached to weakened common cold viruses. 

It comes after it was suggested the NHS would recruit celebrities to encourage people to get vaccinated against the virus, following fears people may reject the jabs.

Moderna has become the second high-profile company to confirm interim results of a clinical trial of its coronavirus vaccine, claiming that the jab is nearly 95 per cent effective

Moderna's vaccine works in the same way as the one developed by Pfizer and BioNTech, by using genetic material called RNA from the coronavirus to trick the body into making the 'spike' proteins that the virus uses to latch onto cells inside the body

Moderna’s vaccine works in the same way as the one developed by Pfizer and BioNTech, by using genetic material called RNA from the coronavirus to trick the body into making the ‘spike’ proteins that the virus uses to latch onto cells inside the body

Today’s announcement follows early results from the trial which suggested it was up to 94.5 per cent effective. These were based on  only five out of 95 people who tested positive in the study had been given the vaccine, compared to 90 who had not.

Responding to today’s release Dr Alexander Edwards, an immunologist at the University of Reading, said: ‘This is great news indeed- the more trial data that we have, the greater confidence we have that vaccines can be used to blunt the human cost of Covid-19. As the numbers of cases reported grows, confidence grows that this amazing protection will be maintained in a product that can be rolled out to protect the public.

‘The most significant part of this news is that we should remember RNA vaccines are really new, and potentially have really significant advantages over some other older types of vaccines. Moderna have also recently announced improvements to the product stability, allowing normal fridge distribution for up to 30 days, and frozen storage in normal (-20) freezers, which will help with logistics.’

Dr Michael Head, senior researcher in global health at the University of Southampton, said: ‘These revised findings are very much in line with those previously announced by Moderna. 

‘This is essentially good news, in that there continues to be a very high level of observed effectiveness, with this effectiveness was consistent across older populations and ethnic minorities. 

‘There were also no serious adverse events caused by the vaccine. We must of course reserve a little caution as we await the final published results, but for now we can retain the existing optimism that this new generation of vaccines may be deployed in the near future.’

Professor Stephen Evans, a pharmacist and epidemiologist at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine said the trial suggest there seems to be ‘no evidence’ that efficacy gets worse at older ages.

‘There seems to be no evidence that efficacy is worse at older ages, though with only a total of 33 aged 65 and over, the uncertainty in these results on their own is considerable,’ he said.

‘The results from blood tests examining immunity may give a better idea of whether the vaccine truly is just as efficacious at older ages as at younger ones, but so far this is again encouraging. 

‘The relatively minor adverse reactions, which are greater after a second than a first dose, are not a real concern. The absence of unexpected severe reactions in 15,000 approximately, who have received the vaccine is very good news also. This means that reactions that occur in more than 1 in 5,000 vaccinated are unlikely to occur. 

‘Rare adverse effects will only be seen after a million or so people have been vaccinated, and it will be important to both be vigilant for these but also not to attribute coincidental events to being caused by the vaccine. Careful follow-up studies will be necessary.’

Professor Azra Ghani, chair in infectious disease epidemiology at Imperial College London, said the results demonstrated a ‘high efficacy’ of the vaccine.

‘The results have been tested across a diverse population and are reported as being consistent in different sub-groups although these numbers are not given and we should wait for further information in the scientific article that is being prepared. 

‘Although not yet reported, the trial includes a secondary endpoint of asymptomatic infection – efficacy against this would be very welcome as it would give the first indication of the broader indirect impact that widespread vaccination could have in reducing onward spread.’

HOW DO THE MODERNA AND PFIZER/BIONTECH VACCINES COMPARE? 

Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech have both released interim results of the final stage clinical trials of their vaccines, with both suggesting they are extremely effective.

Here’s how they compare: 

PFIZER (US) & BIONTECH (DE)

mRNA vaccine – Genetic material from coronavirus is injected to trick immune system into making ‘spike’ proteins and learning how to attack them.

mRNA vaccine – both Moderna’s and Pfizer and BioNTech’s vaccines work in the same way.

94.5% effective (90 positive in placebo group, 5 positive in vaccine group) 

90% effective (estimated 86 positive in placebo group, 9 positive in vaccine group)

US has secured 100million doses for $1.525billion (£1.16bn), suggesting it will cost $15.25 (£11.57) per dose; $30.50 (£23.14) per person.

US will pay $1.95bn (£1.48bn) for the first 100m doses, suggesting a cost of $19.50 (£14.80) per dose; $39 (£29.61) per person.

Vaccine is not expected to be available to Europe until spring 2021, the UK Government says. Moderna will produce 20m doses this year, expected to stay in the US. 

UK has already ordered 40million doses, of which 10million could be available in 2020. First vaccinations expected in December.

What side effects does it cause? 

Moderna said the vaccine is ‘generally safe and well tolerated’. Most side effects were mild or moderate but included pain, fatigue and headache, which were ‘generally’ short-lived. 

Pfizer and BioNTech did not produce a breakdown of side effects but said the Data Monitoring Committee ‘has not reported any serious safety concerns’.